Welcome to Carnival Restaurant
Carnival Restaurant, located in Port Jefferson Station, NY, is a vibrant Italian pizza spot known for its generous portions and authentic flavors. With a diverse menu offering vegan and vegetarian options, this casual yet well-appointed establishment caters to all preferences. From the crispy Fried Calamari to the hearty Zuppa Di Pesce, Carnival impresses with fresh seafood dishes. The standout Brick Oven Margherita Pizza showcases their commitment to quality ingredients. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere make dining here a delightful experience. Don't miss the delectable desserts and the chance to explore their extensive menu offerings.
-
4900 Nesconset Hwy Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 Hotline: (631) 473-9772
Welcome to Carnival Restaurant, a delightful pizzeria and Italian restaurant located in Port Jefferson Station, NY. This establishment offers a wide range of options for pizza lovers and Italian cuisine enthusiasts. With a plethora of amenities such as reservation options, delivery, takeout, vegan and vegetarian choices, and even catering services, Carnival Restaurant caters to various preferences and needs.
When you step into Carnival Restaurant, you are greeted with a cozy and casual ambiance perfect for a laid-back dining experience. With ample parking and attentive waiter service, you are sure to feel welcomed and well taken care of during your visit.
One of the highlights of Carnival Restaurant is their delectable appetizers, including the popular Fried Calamari, Mozzarella in Carrozza, and Hot Antipasto Sampler. These savory starters pave the way for a satisfying meal ahead.
For those craving soups and salads, Carnival Restaurant offers a variety of options such as Pasta Fagioli, Caesar Salad, Beet and Goat Cheese Salad, and more. These dishes are not only flavorful but also made with quality ingredients to ensure a delightful dining experience.
The reviews from patrons like Anthony S., Frank S., Walter K., Alexis F., Christina V., and Stephanie G. showcase the diverse array of dishes available at Carnival Restaurant. Whether it's the Zuppa Di Pesce, the giant garlic knots, or the scrumptious pizza and pasta offerings, each customer has found something to rave about.
Overall, Carnival Restaurant stands out for its excellent food quality, generous portion sizes, and attentive service. With a menu that caters to various dietary preferences and a welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is a must-visit for those looking for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a casual setting.
Classic restaurant with pizza in front and restaurant in the rear. Large portions of southern Italian cuisine. Waiters are courteous and attentive. Try the veal
The eatery is divided into three sections: Pizzeria, restaurant, private dinning area. The decore is lovely and the tables are not close together. We arrived at around 3:00 PM and as soon as we entered we were seated. While the waiter was courteous and quick to serve, everyone in our party felt rushed. It appeared to the table that the waiter wanted us to eat and leave. Given the time of day and the empty room, there was no reason for this. Notwithstanding this, our meals were excellent. We ordered fried calamari and an octopus dish as appetizers. Both were very tasty. I ordered a personal margherita, it was delicious. Beware, the sauce was made with chunky tomatoes, not the regular pizza marinara. For dessert, I ordered a decaf cappuccino and a slice of chocolate fudge cake. The cake was DELICIOUS, the cappuccino not so much. The Takeaways: 1. Excellent parking 2. Service did not come with a smile. 3. At 3:00 PM on a Thursday, no reservations needed. 4. Portion size to price was good. Although, I found it a bit costly for pre- dinner time. 5. Avoid the decaf cappuccino. Final thoughts: Great food, a bit pricy, but worth it.
We come to Carnival about once a month. We love the Zuppa Di Pesce. The seafood is always spot on. Very fresh We typically get the fried zucchini and it's great. This time we ordered a special they had. 2 stuffed mushrooms, 2 baked clams and 2 shrimp oregano. They were excellent. Carnival is always dependable for a great meal
Carnival has the biggest garlic knots I've ever seen! They were the size of my hand and not too garlicky! Their classic cheese slice is a very solid option. We also tried their chicken caprese sandwich which was amazing. Blackened chicken, mozzarella, basil, and a garlic spread on a homemade roll. Everyone at the counter was super nice and helpful too!
Can't believe the renovations here. This place has quadrupled in size since I was a kid. All for the best. They have a $26.50 dinner option on Mondays and Wednesdays that is a steal. They include so many entree options with pasta fagolia which is a meal in itself, or a huuuge salad, glass of wine, coffee and dessert. Portion sizes are big too. These guys do it right by their patrons that have been coming back year after year. The sauce is light with a rich tomato flavor, pasta is al dente. I was upset they were out of the lasagna which is other worldly at their competition, but wanted to try carnival's, so I'll be back. In the meantime, order from the regular menu the eggplant (skin on) with sauce, no cheese but sublime. Full bar, good service, the son Joe manages and he visits tables and talks up his customers. Really nice guy.
This weekend we decided to try Carnival restaurant and pizzeria because I had a giftcard there! I am so glad the gift card pushed me to try them because we had an awesome dinner there. When we sat down they gave us an amazing bread basket with warm fresh bread. (There was also a nice assortment in there so it wasn't just your everyday bread basket) I can kind of tell based on a bread basket alone what kind of experience the meal is going to be so I was really excited when it was a good one. We started out with mozz sticks because I heard they had really amazing home made mozz sticks and they lived up to the hype. My husband said they were the best he's ever had. Then we each decided to get a francese dish. He got shrimp and I got chicken. I let the waiter know that I have a shellfish allergy and he made sure they cooked our dishes seperately. With both meals we opted for a side of penne in the francese sauce. I find that I never really know what I'm going to get when I order chicken at a restaurant. Will it be rubbery? Will the sauce be good? (Nothing turns me off to eating at a restaurant faster than if the chicken is rubbery LOL) you all know what I'm talking about! Luckily the chicken was perfect and the sauce was INCREDIBLE!!! We both agreed we will definitely go back. Service, food and ambiance were all wonderful! And to make it even better you can walk off your meal a bit at homegoods after.